First-time buyers might not know the complicated process when they order a fresh lobster delivery. There are a few things that you will need to prepare for your order. One thing you should determine early on is how much lobster you want to purchase. But we will help you determine that in a minute. First, a lobster lover needs to know the best places to buy their lobster.

Our Top Maine Lobster Delivery Companies

Category Company Most Popular Size Average $/Lobster Dinner* Customer Ratings Go To
Highest Customer Ratings Lobster Anywhere 2 lb. $335 5.0
Best for Sustainability Crab Place 2 lb. $280 4.5
Best for Lobster Tails Cameron’s Seafood 12 oz. $350 4.7
Best Variety Fulton Fish Market 2 lb. $270 4.6
Best for Lobster Meat Wulf’s Fish 1 lb. N/A 4.8
Most Frequent Discounts Get Maine Lobster 1.5 lb. $275 4.9
Best Website Experience Winter Harbor Lobster Co-Op 1.5 lb. $335 4.6
Best for Smaller Lobsters Sanders Lobster Company 1.5 lb. $270 4.5

*Estimated cost of one item in the company’s most popular size.

The above price grid includes information about some of the best lobster companies we have found online. These companies have been singled out because of the quality of their products and their commitment to customer service. For additional sizing options, check out our Maine Lobster Delivery Directory.


Best Places to Order Lobster Fresh Nationally

Fulton Fish Market The fish market, founded in 1822, is one of the country’s oldest fish markets. The market is located in New York City and each day brings in about two million pounds of fresh seafood. The company currently ships its products only to the continental United States.

Global Seafoods North America The seafood company offers a straightforward, easily navigated checkout process. They offer lobster tails in multiple sizes. They also sell lobster claws. For the company’s small scale shipping orders, they contract with UPS.

Get Maine Lobster We regard Get Maine Lobster as among the nation’s finest live lobster companies. They expertly bring live lobster to people’s doorsteps. Maine fishers catch their lobsters. These fishers value the sustainability of the industry. The company sells live lobster, meat, and tails.

The Crab Place If you want all things shellfish, place an order from The Crab Place. The company sells lobsters, crabs, clams, and scallops. We recommend The Crab Place for a first-time lobster eater. They have a low lobster tail order minimum. If you are not sure how much to order the first time, ordering from them is a reliable place to start.

Luke’s Lobster The family-owned Maine seafood business has expanded today into branded grocery. Luke’s Lobster launched its flash-frozen lobster meat, tails, and other seafood meals in stories throughout the country. In 2020, the company further launched its online market to serve lobster lovers around the country.


How Much Lobster Should You Buy?

You should consider a couple of factors when ordering lobster. Appetite, flavor, and side dishes will dictate the quantity of your lobster order.

Appetite – For most orders, you should consider purchasing 2 pounders and above. Your instincts may say to stick with 1.5-pound lobsters per person. However, for standard-sized adults, that amount is not sufficient for one meal. From a 1.5-pound lobster, you might only manage to yield about 5 to 6 ounces. Make sure to always order bigger rather than smaller lobsters to avoid the risk of dissatisfied guests.

Flavor – Those who truly know their lobster will value a sweet flavor. For the best flavor, order 1.25-pound lobsters. Lobster experts generally consider these sized lobsters superior to their larger counterparts. For butter lovers, you might as well order larger lobsters. After all, butter covers the majority of the meat’s true flavor.

Sides – If you plan to offer multiple sides, try to avoid ordering larger lobsters. For instance, with bigger sides or if you choose to make surf and turf, reduce your lobster size by at least a quarter or a half pound. However, if you plan to stick with corn or slaw, keep your lobster order larger. It is also worth mentioning that you consider your drink menu. If you or your guests are planning to drink a lot, you may not want to order the biggest lobsters.

Take note of our Affiliate Relationships that may exist with this page and companies listed on it.