Oysters are a fan-favorite seafood choice that capture the taste of the ocean in one, delicious bite. The best eating experience is shucking a fresh oyster overlooking the waters that the oysters came from. However, we will settle for fresh oysters delivered to your door any day. Oysters you buy online ship directly from the fishers who harvest them. This means you are getting a higher quality product than you would be able to find in a grocery store. We will run through some popular options to buy oysters online, including ways to choose an online company.

Live Oyster Prices

Company Price/doz Minimum Order Shipping Order
Fulton Fish Market $27.76 1 doz $24.24
Crab Place $28.63 1 doz 29.95
Vital Choice $30.00 5 doz FREE


Best Place to Buy Oysters 

The Crab Place offers fresh Chesapeake Bay oysters at a great price for buyers. They sell oysters both intact in the shell and already shucked. You can choose to buy oysters online by the dozen or even by the 100 count. Or, if you would rather not deal with shucking, you can buy shucked oysters by the pint. Additionally, The Crab Place lets you choose your guaranteed delivery date so that you can plan your order ahead of time.

Vital Choice is another great place to get oysters shipped to your door. Unlike some other online sellers, Vital Choice offers a few different varieties of oysters. This is a great option if you are looking to have a sampling of oysters available. You can purchase a 5-dozen bag of their live oysters, which they source from the Pacific coast. To offset the higher cost of fresh oysters, Vital Choice grants free shipping for orders over $99.

Fulton Fish Market has a massive stock of oysters making it the best place to get oysters if you want a lot of options to choose from. You can choose between Pacific of Atlantic oysters then have a field day looking through all the offerings. They have wild and farmed oysters as well as shucked and unshucked ones. You are sure to find the best oysters to order, especially since they have detailed flavor profiles for each oyster type.

Island Creek Oysters harvest their oysters daily and ship their fresh haul straight to your door. You can buy oysters online by the count or you can select one of their oyster packages. One package comes with shucking tools and another is a sampler of some of their oyster varieties. You can even subscribe to an oyster of the month club! Plus, you can read up on their business and practices.


Best Oysters to Buy 

The best place to order oysters online is one that is sustainable and transparent about their methods. These factors are very important to consider when deciding on where to buy oysters or any other seafood online. You will want to know how the company receives their seafood and how they ship to you. The best oysters online will come directly from the people farming or catching the oysters or who source from high-quality third-party fishers. If you cannot find this information, we suggest looking at one of the companies listed above.


Take note of our Affiliate Relationships that may exist with this page and companies listed on it.