Update: The pricing on this page was last updated on 12/8/2020

Crazy Lobster & Shellfish Co Lobster Prices

Lobster Type Min Lobster Order Lobster Price/lb*  Price/4 Lobsters** Expedited Shipping Order
1.25 lb Live Maine Lobster 1 $72.80 $291.2 FREE
1.5 lb Live Maine Lobster 1 $29.00 $166.8 $46.16
2 lb Live Maine Lobster 1 $49.00 $196.46 FREE
3 lb Live Maine Lobster 1 $59 $236.00 FREE
Tails & Meat Minimum Order Lobster Price/Tail* Price for Lobster* Expedited Shipping Order
4-5 oz Lobster Tails 1 $9.99 $89.21 $47.65
7-8 oz Lobster Tails 1 $21.99 $139.13 $47.65
1 lb Fresh Lobster Meat 2 $99.00 $253.57 $47.65

These prices do not include shipping.

** Price for 4 lobsters INCLUDES shipping based on a standardized location. Exact costs may vary.

Get to Know Crazy Lobster & Shellfish Co

Founded: 1957

Address: 244 Columbus Ave, Port Chester, NY 10573

Phone: (914) 481-8899

Contact Email: info@crazylobstershellfish.com

Website: crazylobstershellfish.com


One of the most reliable sources for online lobster delivery, Crazy Lobster and Shellfish Co. has been one of the premiere lobster companies in New England for more than six decades and over three generations of family. Anyone looking for live lobster, tails, cooked meat, and other premium-quality seafood products delivered straight to their door would do well to consider Crazy Lobster & Shellfish Co.


The Crazy Lobster and Shellfish Co uses UPS to deliver their seafood products. Most customers will have two options for live lobster delivery: UPS Next Day Air Saver or UPS Next Day Air. The difference in cost is usually only a dollar, but the difference in delivery is whether your package is prioritized with AM delivery. Remote areas may not receive their shipments until the afternoon regardless. So, this upgrade is usually worth it if you’re going to home during the day to receive the package and immediately cook the lobster or at least keep it chilled in the refrigerator for cooking later in the day.

You can select a date for delivery Tuesday through Saturday, most weeks of the year. Sunday and Monday delivery are not an option. Depending on where you’re getting lobster delivered and how much you’re ordering, the shipping cost is usually somewhere between $40-$70. The company ships throughout the U.S., except for Hawaii, Puerto Rico, U.S. Virgin Islands, and other U.S. territories. Due to custom laws we are unable to ship lobster to international destinations and U.S territories, including, Puerto Rico, and U.S. Virgin Islands and Hawaii. All deliveries must be made to a physical address and should include the recipient’s daytime phone number.

Harvesting Methods

You get only premium, fresh-caught Maine lobster with the Crazy Lobster and Shellfish Co. This is one of the straight from the dock to your door type lobster companies. All of the products are sourced from local fishermen through sustainable fishing practices. Their commitment to quality and sustainable harvesting methods extends beyond their own operations. Their Surf n Turf steaks are antibiotic-free, hormone-free, grass-fed and sourced from small family farms. What started out as a way for local restaurants and stores to source fresh Maine lobster has transformed into a home and business delivery service for live lobster and premium quality seafood.

Recipes and Resources

This company has some of the best recipe and cooking resources we’ve seen. While beginners can find basic tutorials for how to prepare and cook live lobster, more experienced lobster fans can find more advanced instruction parts of the lobster cooking and dining experience. Always had trouble when you try to butterfly your lobster tails? There’s a whole page dedicated just to this topic. Their recipes are also well organized by category (live lobster, tails, meat, shrimp, salmon, shellfish).

Type of Lobster

Live lobster, lobster tails, lobster meat and dinners

Other Seafood Products

Shrimp, salmon, clams, mussels, oysters, scallops and king crab, soups and chowders